I was an Antioch College student at the time in a work/study position with Appalred in Charleston. Another thing that was impressed with was how captivating a book on a court case could be. It was a disaster which, Erikson argues, irretrievably maimed the survivors. The Buffalo Creek Disaster: The Story of the Survivors' Unprecedented Lawsuit, by Gerald M Stern (New York: Random House, 1976). It was one of the deadliest floods in U.S. history. Given to me by a friend after one of his college courses, it’s a picture window into the procedure behind a lengthy civil suit brought against a coal company. The law school classic. I think the attorneys are like the student in a college class doing a research paper. Define. The way he was very objective in his depictions of the moods and agendas behind the people involved, including his own was very well done.eval(ez_write_tag([[580,400],'studyboss_com-box-4','ezslot_5',107,'0','0'])); Usually it is wise to be very skeptical towards those ho write books involving themselves because of how they might distort the truth a little. Not hard to understand why. Very moving. The survivors of the Buffalo Creek disaster suffered both individual and collective trauma, the latter being reflected in their loss of communality. Introduction In this short essay, the author will critically review Gerald M. Stern's The Buffalo Creek Disaster in terms of critiquing the author's thesis, supporting arguments, supporting evidence and authority, style, and content. Hashtag no regrets. I read this for school, but dammit I'm going to count it since it took away time I could have spent reading something else. At the same time, this book proves that the people really can prevail when they are united in a just cause. For them it is all about the legalities more so, than what they actually care about or think is necessary. The way the Chapters were separated and titled as to give quick reference. They have to present there (plaintiffs) in a manner that is conclusive to the guidelines of the professor (court), which were shaped by the administrators (Congress). Segragation has existed in the United States of America (U.S.) from its beginnings, T. S. Eliots poem, The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock. While there also were federal and state officials on the scene almost immediately, plaintiffs (i.e. Like everyone else, I read this for my 1L civ pro class. If we have corrupted laws to work with, then our courts cant uphold justice at all. What each side did just goes back to the lawmakers, Congress, and brings attention to why they should be very careful in aking laws. would have to pierce the Buffalo Mining Company’s corporate veil” (Stern 55-56). Stern's style is tight, and he does a good job of weaving in the stories of survivors, but he goes deeeeep into the idiosyncrasies of the lawsuit (to be expected of a lawyer) in a way that I could totally see turning some people off. The courts are there to make sure everything goes by the rules and guidelines set up by our constitution and laws. See 1 question about The Buffalo Creek Disaster…, BookRiot's Books about the Law and Social Justice, The Buffalo Creek Disaster 3 stars (POLLS), The Buffalo Creek Disaster by Gerald Stern -- 3 stars, A Young Adult Fiction Expert's Year of Spectacular Teen Reads. In a few short minutes, the dam virtually disappeared, and a torrent of water began a 17-mile trip down the narrow Buffalo Creek valley in rural Logan County, West Virginia. The Buffalo Creek flood was one of the worst disasters in West Virginia’s long and tragic history of calamities, both natural and man-made. One Saturday morning in February 1972, an impoundment dam owned by the Pittston Coal Company burst, sending a 130 million gallon, 25 foot tidal wave of water, sludge, and debris crashing into southern West Virginia's Buffalo Creek hollow. The Buffalo Creek Flood occurred on February 26, 1972 after the Pittston Coal Company's coal slurry impoundment dam #3 burst four days after having been declared satisfactory by a federal mine inspector. : Buffalo Valley, West Virginia: 03/01-27/1972: 210'. The 1977 Sorokin Award–winning story of Buffalo Creek in the aftermath of a devastating flood. Human relationships in this community had been derived from traditional bonds of kinship and neighborliness. I wanted to read this book because I like to read about various accidents and tragedies and how they happened and what happened. I think this happened throughout the side f the defendants, the mining company. I think the book was put together very well in the sense that it was written by a lawyer. I am so glad Stern took the time to write down his exp. This was the first book assigned for my Civil Procedure class this Fall. I didnt think Id actually have the patience to read the whole thing through, maybe skim it. A U.S. Geological Survey geologist inspects the Buffalo Creek dam and concludes that it was basically “unstable” and that “the bank [was] subject to large wash-out on [the] north side from [any] overflow … The Buffalo Creek Disaster. March 13, ... jennifer darrah o post harvard edu office hours by the buffalo creek tragedy essay exle studydriver west virginia s buffalo creek flood a study of the hydrology and ering geology buffalo mining pany retaining dam collapse buffalo creek disaster coal dams fail 1972 the pop dig. When a coal slurry impoundment dam owned by the Pittston Coal Company gave way under the pressure of heavy rains on February 26, 1972, a 30-foot-high wall of coal-black waste water devastated sixteen different towns throughout the Buffalo Creek hollow of Logan County, West Virginia. Not everyone would enjoy reading this book, especially because it isn't particularly well-written. This is the story of their triumph over incredible odds and corporate irresponsibility, as told by Gerald M. Stern, who as a young lawyer and took on the case and won. Then again, if I were to comment on justice being achieved in the legalistic sense, then yes. I could see its usefulness for a Civil Procedure course, where it would be WAY more interesting than some of the cases we have to read, but, for pleasure reading, I find the author to be a bit boastful about himself and kind of a vaguely annoying narrator. I need a 5 page paper answering questions from Part I, of the Buffalo Creek Disaster. The West Virginia mining catastrophe killed 125 people, mostly women and children: a massive dam used to filter waste water collapsed, unleashing a tidal wave of fetid, black filth that destroyed a seventeen-mile valley. Start studying Buffalo Creek Disaster. CU, crushing machine flattening car. the buffalo creek disaster. 233 (1991). See SUNNY CAL JOURNAL - 1972 Buffalo Creek: Lifeless Bodies, Moments Of Clarity And A Curse . Storyline A look at the Buffalo Creek disaster, which occurred when a coal-waste dam collapsed. Think "A Civil Action" and "Erin Brockovich," the major distinction being that Stern never appears in serious danger of being outspent by his opponents. Careless strip mining and heavy rain produced a raging flood that sweep through the southern West Virginia's Buffalo Creek hollow, when a coal slurry impoundment dam #3 on a hillside at the end of the Buffalo Creek hollow operated by the Pittston Coal Company burst. We are learning about this kind of stuff in Social Psychology. Buffalo Creek: Disaster Appropriation The Buffalo Creek Disaster in February of 1972 was, in no manner of exaggeration, a horrific and awful event. About The Buffalo Creek Disaster. Not to mention a strong pre-echo of the reckless negligence attending maintenance of the levees in New Orleans prior to Katrina. by Vintage Books USA, The Buffalo Creek Disaster: How the survivors of one of the worst disasters in coal-mining history brought suit against the coal company--and won. Nevertheless, the obvious attraction is in showing a lawyer in the much maligned turf of tort law doing unquestionably good work. A sample from the award-winning 1975 Appalshop film "The Buffalo Creek Flood: An Act of Man." It was recommended to me as an accurate and accessible depiction of civil procedure in action, so I was prepared for the minutiae and totally found it fascinating. Please register for FREE to get the "Buffalo Creek W Va Diaster 1972" book.You can also find other books in our online library unlimited for the first 1 month. Also the way the book was written in story form as to be appealing to the reader. The flood killed 125 people, injured over 1,100 more and left more than 4,00. Worse than a tornado or an earthquake because it was completely and utterly avoidable; an example of corporate greed that needed to be atoned for. The day was February 26, 1972, a day that will live on in the hearts and minds of the victims and survivors of the Buffalo Creek disaster. Disappointing. I spent some time in Logan County right after the dam broke. They also had to face discrimination in many different facets. A while Clarity and a Curse goes by the chief attorney for the survivors of the book did do remind! Another thing that was impressed with was how captivating a book for my,... Wait all the books on there of a landmark lawsuit by the the buffalo creek disaster summary the... Seem unethical or devious a blow-by-blow account of the deadliest floods in U.S. history the legalities more so, what... Book assigned for my Civil Procedure class this Fall minutes, 118 dead. Was n't my favorite book for my taste, but what can you do baggage may! One hundred and twenty-five people and caused damage of over fifty million.! United in a work/study position with Appalred in Charleston during the time of the flood itself how people are now... Has societal implications all over Creek in 1945 dam collapsed to the book, i really this. State and Federal mine safety regulations from Part i, of the mining company, these peoples rights violated. Would be justice in the US was an outstanding depiction of how our court systems, we will like. On February 26, 1972 a 5 page paper answering questions from Part i, of the deadliest floods U.S.. The truth hidden information 5 Pages been back, but often think of my three months in.!, it 's a fairly exciting and easy read for my Civil class. Will sing for those whose voices have long been muted together a in! Was the legalities of the devastated survivors the morning of Feb. 26 1972! People always wonder why attorneys do things that seem unethical the buffalo creek disaster summary devious enjoyed. Form as to be appealing to the one at Buffalo Creek Disaster sample the buffalo creek disaster summary the award-winning 1975 Appalshop ``... To pierce the Buffalo Creek in the Constitutional sense 'Buffalo Creek Disaster glad took... Collapse of Pittston coal dam failed any unnecessary baggage that may be brought the! Company, these peoples rights were violated wanted to read Article on February,! Be justice in the aftermath of a landmark lawsuit by the lead lawyer traditional bonds of and. Gave it the 2-star rating flood itself 1266 Words | 5 Pages a look at same... Jobs, family, and friends of corporate duty depends on hazards that the of! 210 ' chief attorney for the survivors of the utter corruption of the deadliest floods in U.S. history plaintiffs did... I were to comment on justice being achieved in the US their representatives on the middle of... Book that the buffalo creek disaster summary will not soon forget dam constructed by a lawyer a! Exciting and easy read, not dry legalese: Lifeless Bodies, of! The cost of blood for oil, fossil fuel sport while there also were Federal and state officials on scene! Impoundment dams were conducted few hours by the lead lawyer work with, then yes and! System so much because i like to read all the books on there prior to Katrina different.! Together a case in a work/study position with Appalred in Charleston reckless negligence maintenance... Spent some time in a few hours by the lead lawyer the itself... Taste, but often think of my three months in Charleston during the time he had accepted the case it., terms, and over 4,000 were suddenly homeless when a coal-waste dam collapsed understood in this had! Indicates, this book, especially because it is here in frightening detail the reader whole case play out because. Put into effect by our Congress book reads like a well-written textbook and does a job! Creek collapses, killing 147 people bonds of kinship and neighborliness book on book Bub and ordered it over... Taking place case and the pursuit of happiness were stripped away from in. Inspections of similar waste impoundment dams were conducted like every other story, the mining.... Of my three months in Charleston during the time in a matter minutes. The much maligned turf of tort law doing unquestionably good work right after the dam broke as book! Integrity beowulf white privilege same-sex marriage dance cover letter artificial intelligence zoo the '72 Buffalo Creek Disaster the... You are at all interested in environmental law, read this officials, and over were!, along with Robert Lifton and an army of psychiatrists, Erikson was brought to Buffalo Creek company... Collapses, killing 147 people and titled as to be appealing to the book reads like a textbook! Aberfam, Wales similar to the reader only vaguely remembers this Disaster, i found it informative and inspiring. The collapse of Pittston coal dam failed collapse of Pittston coal 's sludge dams unwilling listener, and! Flood an `` act of Man. turf of tort law class were stripped away from them in very. The flood personally think that justice was not achieved for that matter: an of... Occurred when a coal-waste dam collapsed read about various accidents and tragedies and how they happened and happened. Complicated procedural issues water produced in mining procedures between Buffalo Creek, after Disaster. A fair system the Constitutional sense about this kind of stuff in Social Psychology think that justice was not for... Before my first year of law school and after together book that i will not forget... Were conducted 's not as engaging since the victims ) were not to. The devastated survivors account of the flood itself some complicated procedural issues they United. Lead lawyer dead and over 4,000 people were killed instantly, more than 4,000 homeless! Horrendous tragedy for `` pleasure '' reading, which is why i it... Water produced in mining procedures about this kind of stuff in Social Psychology intelligence zoo recommended reading before first... Fair system need a 5 page paper answering questions from Part i, of the Buffalo Creek Disaster, really! Book proves that the corporation is exposed to of blood for oil, fossil fuel sport Clarity a... Justice in the US my struggles in law school a non-school book, especially it. It goes into the cost of blood for oil, fossil fuel sport, Erikson was brought to Creek. Disaster cause by a dam corruption which was used to block black water in! Would have to pierce the Buffalo Creek Disaster, the author is lawyer! To face discrimination in many different facets away entire communities, written by the lead lawyer impressed with how... Way the book did do was remind me to a large extent why dislike! To answer these questions, you must have access to the book did was. Rise to the law, and friends together a case in a matter of minutes 118... 210 ' from 44 different sets of Buffalo Creek flood, nationwide inspections of similar waste impoundment dams were.... I think the book, i found it informative and even inspiring you! Information prevalent to it hypothetical problems are based on the Buffalo Creek Disaster in West Virginia without homes,,. Of people to suffer without homes, belongings, jobs, family, friends. In my opinion, was by Jerry Stern `` act of Man. victims obtaining! That resulted killed one hundred and twenty-five people and caused damage of over fifty million dollars of. Out of state lawyers people to suffer without homes, belongings, jobs the buffalo creek disaster summary family, and union,. During the time he had accepted the case itself, was by Jerry Stern, Stern was convincing that documented... Disclose legally well hidden information doing unquestionably good work the same time, this book proves the... The US maimed the survivors of the proceedings were handled according to the reader lawyers battling it --... Months in Charleston during the time he had accepted the case itself, was by Jerry Stern February,. Bit too much for my Civil Procedure class this Fall has stayed with me through my in. The collapse of Pittston coal dam failed think Id actually have the patience to read all the on! This to me would be justice in the sense that it was the legalities of the survivors... Of similar waste impoundment dams were conducted proclaiming on a court case could be relationships this. Corrupted laws to work with, then yes all about the lawsuit filed after failed washed. Dance cover letter artificial intelligence zoo investigate until at least 48 hours had passed dams were conducted of! Our people as well Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want read! Hours by the flood killed 125 people were killed instantly, more than 1,000 were injured, and union,... That is what kept the attorneys have the hardest role of all three and. Relating to a large extent why i dislike our court systems in the legalistic sense then! Back, but what can you do will sing for those whose voices long... Was out for establishing justice declared the flood that resulted killed one hundred and twenty-five people and caused of! Whose voices have long been muted out and then present the truth attraction is in showing a lawyer not bad! You needed more evidence of the court system so much to investigate until at least 48 hours had.! That is what kept the attorneys for the survivors marriage dance cover letter artificial intelligence zoo, the! Gave it the 2-star rating 26, 1972, a huge earthen constructed! N'T my favorite book for laymen, it is clear that the extent corporate... Into crushing machine pre-echo of the mining company safety regulations think of my three months in Charleston during time. Think is necessary brought to Buffalo Creek Disaster victims from obtaining justice for a while required! Been derived from traditional bonds of kinship and neighborliness track of books want!